Fender Flares: Plastic vs. Metal

Choosing the Right Material for Your Fender Flares: Plastic vs. Metal

Fender Flares for Different Climate Conditions: What to Consider Reading Choosing the Right Material for Your Fender Flares: Plastic vs. Metal 7 minutes Next Common Fender Flare Installation Mistakes to Avoid

Fender Flares: Plastic vs. Metal If you're an automotive enthusiast or someone looking to upgrade their vehicle.

You've likely come across the dilemma of choosing the right material for your fender flares.

Fender flares are those stylish extensions that not only enhance your vehicle's aesthetics but also serve a practical purpose.

They provide additional coverage to your tires, protecting your vehicle's body from debris and mud.

When it comes to fender flare materials, two options stand out: plastic and metal.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll dive deep into the world of fender flares and explore the pros and cons of plastic and metal options.

Helping you make an informed decision for your prized possession.

Understanding the Importance of Fender Flares

Before we delve into the specifics of plastic and metal fender flares, let's take a moment to understand why they are important.

Fender flares offer several benefits:

Enhanced Protection

Fender flares provide an extra layer of protection to your vehicle's body. They prevent rocks, mud, and other debris from being thrown onto your vehicle's sides, reducing the risk of paint chipping and dents.

Customizable Style

One of the most noticeable advantages of fender flares is the opportunity to customize your vehicle's appearance. They come in various styles and widths, allowing you to achieve the look you desire.

Legal Compliance

Fender Flares: Plastic vs. Metal In many places, fender flares are required by law, especially if you have oversized tires.

Installing them ensures you stay compliant with local regulations.

Now, let's dive into the comparison between plastic and metal fender flares.

The Pros and Cons of Plastic Fender Flares

Pros of Plastic Fender Flares


One of the most significant advantages of plastic fender flares is their affordability. They are generally more budget-friendly than their metal counterparts, making them an attractive option for those on a tight budget.


Plastic fender flares are considerably lighter than metal ones. This weight advantage can improve your vehicle's fuel efficiency and handling, especially for off-road enthusiasts.

Easy to Install

Installing plastic fender flares is a relatively straightforward process. You can often do it yourself with basic tools, saving money on installation costs.

Rust Resistance

Unlike metal, plastic does not rust. This means that plastic fender flares are more durable in wet and corrosive environments.

Cons of Plastic Fender Flares

Limited Durability

While plastic fender flares are resistant to rust, they are more susceptible to cracks and damage from impacts.

They may not hold up as well in rugged off-road conditions.


Some enthusiasts argue that plastic fender flares don't offer the same level of aesthetics as metal ones.

They may not provide the rugged, premium appearance that some vehicle owners desire.

The Pros and Cons of Metal Fender Flares

Pros of Metal Fender Flares

Exceptional Durability

Metal fender flares, typically made from materials like steel or aluminum, are incredibly durable.

They can withstand impacts and rough terrain, making them ideal for off-road enthusiasts.

Premium Aesthetics

Metal fender flares often exude a premium and rugged appearance. They can give your vehicle a unique and eye-catching look.


Metal fender flares can be painted to match your vehicle's color perfectly, ensuring a seamless and integrated look.

Cons of Metal Fender Flares


Compared to plastic, metal fender flares are significantly heavier. This added weight can have a negative impact on fuel efficiency and handling.


Metal fender flares are generally more expensive than plastic ones. If you're on a tight budget, this might be a significant drawback.

Installation Complexity

Installing metal fender flares can be more challenging and may require professional assistance.

This adds to the overall cost.

Making Your Decision on Fender Flares: Plastic vs. Metal

Now that you're armed with the pros and cons of both plastic and metal fender flares, it's time to make a decision. Consider the following factors:


If cost is a primary concern, plastic fender flares may be the way to go. They offer good protection at a fraction of the price of metal flares.

Intended Use

Think about how you plan to use your vehicle. If you're an avid off-roader and need maximum durability, metal fender flares are the better choice.

On the other hand, if you mainly drive on paved roads, plastic flares may suffice.


Consider the look you want to achieve. If you want a rugged, premium appearance, metal fender flares are the winner in this category.


Evaluate your DIY skills and willingness to tackle installation. If you're handy with tools, plastic fender flares can be a straightforward DIY project.

However, if you prefer a professional touch, metal flares may be the better option despite the higher installation cost.

To further aid your decision-making process, here are some links to reputable sources on fender flares:

4 Wheel Parts - Fender Flares Buying Guide
ExtremeTerrain - Plastic vs. Metal Fender Flares
CARiD - Choosing the Right Fender Flares

These sources provide additional insights and expert opinions on the topic.


In the world of automotive customization, the choice between plastic and metal fender flares ultimately comes down to your priorities and intended use.

Plastic flares offer affordability and ease of installation, while metal flares provide unmatched durability and premium aesthetics.

Consider your budget, how you plan to use your vehicle, the look you desire, and your installation preferences when making your decision.

With the right fender flares, you can protect your vehicle and make a style statement on the road.


Are plastic fender flares suitable for off-road use?

Plastic fender flares can be suitable for off-road use, but they may not withstand rugged terrain and impacts as well as metal flares. If off-roading is a significant part of your driving experience, you might want to consider metal fender flares for their durability.

Can I paint plastic fender flares to match my vehicle's color?

Yes, you can paint plastic fender flares to match your vehicle's color. This allows for customization and a seamless appearance.

Do metal fender flares rust?

Metal fender flares can rust, especially if they are made of steel and exposed to moisture. However, aluminum fender flares are more resistant to rust.

Are there any legal requirements for fender flares?

In many places, there are legal requirements for fender flares, especially if you have oversized tires. It's essential to check local regulations to ensure compliance.

Can I install fender flares myself, or do I need professional assistance?

The ease of installation depends on the type of fender flares and your DIY skills. Plastic fender flares are often easier to install and can be done by DIY enthusiasts. Metal fender flares may require professional installation, especially if you're not experienced with automotive modifications.